Should we abolish academic papers? Picturing the Future of Science.
IAS Festival Reflections by Carina Pepene
As part of the IAS Festival, students attended sessions and wrote a short reflection connecting the discussions within society to their own perspectives. This piece is connected to the session 'Pathways towards an otherwise science: Mapping priorities and inspiring alternatives'.

Science, it almost seems, finds itself in a disastrous state. "Not inclusive enough." "Not enough diversity." "Lack of humility, love, care..." These words, amongst others, were down on a whiteboard as diagnoses for the state of science alongside the echoes of abolishing academic papers. Yet, the beauty of science lies exactly there: through centuries, science has been reinventing itself.
In a room full of diverse voices: from students to retired researchers, from artists to physicists, we all sat down in IAS's library to imagine the future of science. It sounds like a tedious task for a small group of around 20 people, and it did indeed feel heavy, yet liberating. The session was organized by two "futurists" (individuals who study and explore the future): dr. Roanne van Voorst (Assistant Professor in Futures-Anthropology, University of Amsterdam) and dr. Tessa Cramer (Professor Designing the Future, Fontys Applied Sciences) who invited us to imagine science otherwise, to picture what it could look like if built from different assumptions entirely.
"Abolish academic papers", adds jokingly (or not) a voice from the audience. The room fills with nervous laughter, in sympathy with the researcher's concerns as she explains how unrealistic the pace asked of scientists is, and how futile it is to measure one's academic success by the number of publications.
The issue runs deeper, of course- it's not only about human exhaustion or the surface-level inquisition imposed on researchers through quantification. Scientific journals are now flooded with AI-generated pieces, making it even more difficult to distinguish what is human-produced from what is not, what is high-quality from what is mere slop. Citizens have equally lost their faith in science, which has become a disputable domain: what is factual and what is not, what is opinion-based and what is proven.
After a round of introductions, we were divided into three clusters to reflect on distinct dimensions of an otherwise science: knowing differently, publishing and valuing differently, and working and learning differently. I picked the first category, drawn to it instinctively, perhaps because it felt like the most fundamental question: what counts as knowledge in the first place?
I found myself seated next to an artist who immediately raised the question of "embodied" ways of knowing via the senses, two scenography students, arts practitioners and a physicist. We received a worksheet prompting reflection on "Co-Creating with Society," "The Affective Turn," "Science for the Planet," and "Technology and Science." Then, we had to rank them, but instead, we drew a picture depicting an umbrella: Technology raining down from above on the scientific world, with "Co-Creating with Society" as the umbrella itself sheltering "The Affective Turn" and "Science for the Planet" beneath it. To me, our image captured something the conversation kept circling back to: science needs to become more open, both internally among disciplines and externally toward society at large.
What I appreciated most about the afternoon, besides the excellent slices of cake, was how it brought such diverse voices into one room (still not sufficiently diverse, perhaps). Hopefully, the upcoming series held by Futures Reframed at IAS from September onwards will push that inclusivity barrier further. To quote IAS director Huub, when asked about the irony of the setting (a library with no books): "You are the books." So, there is, perhaps, still hope for science to evolve as it always has used the human mind, as an open book toward something more something better, more equitable, more diverse and more enjoyable.