POLDER: Unravelling Complexity
IAS Festival Reflections by Sophie Boylan
As part of the IAS Festival, students attended sessions and wrote a short reflection connecting the discussions within society to their own perspectives. This piece is connected to the session 'POLDER: Unravelling complexity'.

How do you talk to policymakers about complexity, without mentioning complexity? This is one of the many challenges facing complexity scientists seeking to bring their insights to the forefront of policy decisions. There is growing consensus that policy making needs reform, that the intricacies of our social systems are rarely conducive to simple models, and that rigid, linear, one-dimensional approaches to societal problem-solving are no longer viable. Complexity science presents an immense opportunity to improve and optimise decision-making at a policy level, and the evidence for this is already clear: across the work of Brian Castellani and the academics at POLDER, applications of complexity science have spanned issues as diverse as healthy eating initiatives in the Netherlands and water contamination solutions in South Africa.
However, overcoming the human bias towards simplicity and linearity to convince stakeholders that many problems are best solved with a complexity approach is no easy task. At POLDER’s roundtable discussion, academics working in the field cited numerous examples of the difficulties they had met with when trying to present systems-thinking or computational modelling approaches to organisations. From claims that their models were “too complex”, to outright dismissals that the problem must be simply unsolvable, almost every scientist seemed to have a story to tell of resistance and persuasion. A common undercurrent emerged: the difficulty of translating complexity science for the non-scientific organisations that would most benefit from it. Consequently, the academics at POLDER have developed strategies to translate the science into digestible terms.
One such strategy is to simply not mention complexity at all. Where “complex” is seen as a synonym for “unsolvable” or “uncontrollable”, the term may be best omitted. Rather, it can be highlighted how a change at one point in a system influences changes elsewhere, without referring to the complex nature of these interactions. A second tactic is to break a complex model down into simpler sub-models and frame it within a narrative structure that is more easily communicable to an unversed audience. As a proactive measure, explicitly acknowledging uncertainty within the model can serve to level stakeholders’ expectations and prevent assumptions of infallibility.
Beyond cynicism, other hurdles are often organisational in nature. For example, how do complexity scientists maintain long-term relationships with policymakers, when these public service positions often resemble revolving doors, continuously ushering in new staff members who each require a fresh acquaintance with the model. Not least, the misalignment of academic timeframes with those of public policy presents its own complications. For complexity applications to be effective, sincere buy-in is required from stakeholders, at all levels of the chain of command. In reality, what is often observed is a concentration of interest that results in the exclusion of players from the highest and lowest rungs of the organisation. In sum, institutions must be receptive, flexible and actively engaged, if complex approaches are to have a lasting impact.
Yet it is not just external constraints that hamper the work of complexity scientists. According to Brian Castellani, the field must look inward, too. Complex models often lack consideration of crucial factors. For one, the people involved in the models are subject to their own limitations; burnout and loss of interest are two inevitable factors that models should be resilient against. Alongside a changing workforce, government systems themselves are subject to new developments, and models should be invulnerable to such change. Finally, interdisciplinarity cannot just be a theoretical aspiration, it must be actively maintained to guarantee that models are incorporating insights from wide-ranging fields.
And so, how do you talk to policymakers about complexity, without arousing the resistance that the term often elicits? POLDER believes that the way forward lies in education, or, as Brian Castellani put it, “academic overhaul”. That is why POLDER have launched the Master’s programme in Complex Systems and Policy at the UvA, paving the way for a generation of policymakers who have had complexity science integrated into their social sciences education. Until then, POLDER is working with government ministries in an educational capacity, focusing on teaching modelling solutions and systems thinking, for application to policy. With these efforts underway, we can hope for a future where complexity can be discussed, not only without fear of resistance, but as an integral aspect to every policy decision.