In a room filled with people from all academic backgrounds and disciplines, Prof. Han van der Maas led a talk centring around one question: How useful is the complex-systems approach in the study of humans?

Firstly, what are complex systems? They are systems consisting of many components that interact non-linearly, with other characteristics including feedback loops and emergence (a topic that received its own talk during the festival). Common examples of complex systems are the Earth's climate, infrastructure, and the human brain.

The audience seemed to reflect the breadth of fields where complex systems are being studied, with backgrounds ranging from physics to philosophy to the social sciences. One member of the audience, a former fellow at IAS, is researching global conceptions of blackness through the prism of emergence and evolution of race across normative and institutional networks. Another audience member was a philosopher with a recently acquired an interest in complex-systems approaches through ontology, arguing that the nature of being can itself be considered a complex system.

Van der Maas, himself a Professor of Psychological Methods at UvA, made the relevance of the question to his field of research clear. As the author of a book specifically on complex-systems research in psychology, and whose self-proclaimed mission it is to "apply formal models and methods from complex system research in the social and behavioural sciences", he seemed to have a natural inclination towards a conclusion in favour of complex-systems approaches. After briefly explaining his own work on network psychology, the floor was given to those present to discuss the applicability of the complex-systems approach in the study of humans. Particularly intriguing here was the invitation by Prof. Van der Maas to provide counterarguments to the complex-systems approach.

Some of the arguments raised focused on the level of analysis used when adopting the complex-systems approach: social phenomena might be better understood through simplification, but how useful are these simplified models? Similarly, by continuously zooming in to more accurately reflect system interactions and relevant variables, models risk becoming too computationally demanding to be practically workable.

Another critique levelled at the use of complex-systems approaches in the social sciences centred around the often metaphorical nature they can take, using terms such as 'tipping points' and 'phase transitions' without these carrying the mathematical precision found in physics. Such metaphorical nomenclature might still have conceptual value, but risks becoming difficult to falsify.

One audience member proposed a limitation inherent in complex-systems approaches to the study of humans – namely, the subject of study: humans. Unlike in most other fields, the subjects of study can actually reflect on their own state, potentially invalidating models once these become known. While this was originally presented as a problem unique to psychology and the social sciences, the physicists in the room begged to differ. This phenomenon, they argued, is also present in quantum physics, opening the door to a discussion on the use of quantum models in the study of humans.

Prof. Van der Maas concluded this discussion by highlighting some predicted critiques – most of which were raised by the audience – and provided brief but convincing rebuttals to all of them. Throughout this exchange of views on the applicability of the complex-systems approach, one thing stood out to me: all of these academics from this diverse range of disciplines were commonly enthralled by the study of complex systems. The complex-systems approach was universally embraced by those present, and it became apparent that this paradigm provides a language that all present could speak – many with great fluency – no matter their background; the complex-systems approach as a lingua franca.