Interdisciplinary Approaches to Environmental Problem-Solving
Solving the problem of climate change requires collective efforts from individuals, communities, governments, and industries. Similarly, addressing the research of this complex and complicated problem necessitates collaboration across various disciplines. On June 1, 2023, Mikhail Anufriev and Jan Tuinstra organized a multidisciplinary workshop at IAS that brought together economists, computer scientists, and practitioners from different fields. The purpose of this workshop was to facilitate the sharing of their latest research efforts and methods applied to the issues of climate change mitigation and adaptation.
Trademarks, Footprints, and Network Science
Where do environmental innovations originate? What are the drivers of environmental innovations? And why do regions play a key role in environmental innovations? Carolina Castaldi, a Professor in the Geography of Innovation at Utrecht University, explores these questions in the emerging field of the geography of innovation. By combining patent data, traditionally used to measure innovativeness, with trademark data that accounts for a broader range of sectors and organizations while also reflecting the downstream propagation of innovations, it becomes possible to quantify the positive effect of both firms' existing technological capabilities and green policies on innovativeness in environmental areas.
This approach allows for better accounting of the impact of environmentally innovative products, ensuring the inclusion of their potential negative production impact on the environment. Economist Dr. Daan in 't Veld, from the Netherlands Environmental Assessment Agency (PBL), utilizes network science to analyze input-output data, enabling the calculation of environmental footprints and providing quantitative measures of progress towards a circular economy. As the Netherlands aims to achieve full circularity by 2050, this methodology facilitates the development of greenhouse gas and land footprint targets, which can complement existing national energy and climate objectives in the pursuit of circularity.
Small Communities, Global Cooperation and Tipping Points
Successful mitigation of climate change relies heavily on cooperation across various societal levels, spanning from local communities to nations. Dr. Vítor Vasconcelos, a complexity scientist affiliated with the University of Amsterdam and Princeton University, combines theoretical insights from evolutionary game theory with computational experiments to identify the conditions that foster sustainable cooperation. His research underscores the pivotal role of small groups, where cooperation is more attainable and lasting. However, it is equally important to establish global institutions once initial cooperation has been achieved, as they can enhance the efficacy of local initiatives.
The specific feedback mechanisms between individuals and the environment, as well as the extent of forward-thinking behavior, are crucial for sustaining cooperation. Dr. Ir. Florian Wagener, an Associate Professor at the University of Amsterdam and a fellow of the Tinbergen Institute, explores these dynamics by considering rational and strategic decision-making. Through the application of differential games and optimal control techniques, he reveals that in systems with tipping points, commonly found in socioeconomic and environmental domains, the predictions of simple linear models of the impossibility of large coalitions significantly change. Whereas in these tipping point systems cooperation becomes more critical, as surpassing tipping points leads to greater environmental losses, the good news is that it also becomes more feasible to achieve larger and stable coalitions.
Studying the Interplay between Inequality and Environmental Adaptation using ABM
ABM, or Agent-Based Modeling, is increasingly utilized in economic and climate studies as a versatile tool for understanding the complex dynamics of climate systems and the bounded rationality of human interactions, drawing insights from various disciplines such as sociology, psychology, and economics. Martina Magličić, a Ph.D. student at the University of Amsterdam and the Institute of Environmental Science and Technology at the University Autonoma Barcelona, focuses on examining the interplay between inequality and the adoption of environmentally friendly products (such as solar panels, for example). In her ABM, peer effects, environmental awareness, and social concerns all may drive environmental adaptation. However, the significant cost barrier for lower-income groups keeps them locked in with the old technologies exacerbating inequality.
This underscores the importance of targeted policies that specifically address the financial constraints faced by lower-income groups to achieve an effective and equitable energy transition. Tatiana Filatova, a Professor in Computational Economics at the Delft University of Technology, utilizes survey and experimental data in an ABM of coastal housing markets, revealing that household responses to floods lead to market sorting, potentially exacerbating climate gentrification and trapping low-income households in high-risk areas. The findings further emphasize the necessity for coordinated institutional action and well-designed adaptation policies to enhance urban resilience against climate-induced floods.
Whither Experimental Economics?
In addition to bringing together experienced researchers, early career researchers, and Ph.D. students from various disciplines, this workshop explored the potential contributions of experimental economics in climate studies. Jan Tuinstra, Professor of Mathematical Economics at the University of Amsterdam and a fellow of the Tinbergen Institute, highlighted the value of controlled experiments with incentivized participants in individual and group decision-making tasks. Despite a large variability in methodologies, each of the six workshop presentations discussed above provides opportunities to formulate and test hypotheses regarding human behavior. Overall, the workshop opened new avenues and gave us hope that fruitful collaborations can lead to success in tackling climate change.