Debating causation and Polygenic risk with Prof James Woodward
On 12 May 2023, professor James Woodward, renowned philosopher of science, visited the IAS to discuss two of his papers. Woodward is a distinguished Professor in the Department of History and Philosophy of Science at the University of Pittsburgh and has contributed debates on causation, explanation, and modeling in the sciences.
Presentation
Woodward was invited to discuss two of his papers. The first paper, A Functional Account of Causation published in 2014, offers a view on causation that differs from the metaphysical accounts or the descriptive approaches that attempt to reconstruct intuitions. In this paper, Woodward advocates an approach to causation that is couched in terms of the goals and purposes of causal thinking. The second paper that Woodward presented was Polygenic Risk Scores: A Philosophical Exploration, which he coauthored with professor Kenneth Kendler. Polygenic risk scores summarize the estimated association between individual single nucleotide polymorphisms obtained from genome wide association studies, and phenotypic traits (e.g., height, liability to a disease, educational attainment). In this paper, Kenler and Woodward explore the causal interpretation of these polygenic risk scores.
Discussion
Two researchers offered commentary on the presentation. Dr. Jolien Francken commented on A Functional Account of Causation. She focused on the issue of correlation vs. causation, and to what extent Woodward's notion of causation could be beneficial for empirical research in the field of neuroscience of consciousness. Professor Reinout Wiers commented on Polygenic Risk Scores: A Philosophical Exploration. He explored how different ideas on risk at population level could influence an individual, with the case of children of alcohol-dependent parent(s). Woodward actually wrote a related piece with Ken Kendler emphasizing this as one of the cases for downward causation. The case of Mendelian Randomisation as means of causal inference was also briefly discussed.
The event concluded with a lively debate, with topics ranging from the choice of variables to supervenience relations.