Event details from: Computational modelling of school choice and school segregation: from theoretical to data-driven agent-based models

Date
14 December 2023
Time
11:00 – 12:00
Room
Library

Title

Computational modelling of school choice and school segregation: from theoretical to data-driven agent-based models

Abstract

Many educational systems still consist of substantial levels of school segregation along various lines, such as race, ethnicity, household income levels, parental educational attainment and ability. This means that, globally, pupils with similar characteristics cluster together in the same schools. This is widely acknowledged to reproduce or even exacerbate inequalities and result in unequal outcomes. Hence, even despite decades of research and policies aimed to counteract school segregation, it is still a persistent societal problem. Existing literature shows that factors affecting school segregation and individual components in the system of school choice interact with each other.

These interactions are reasoned to be an important mechanism through which the levels of school segregation emerge on the macro-level, but commonly used qualitative and quantitative analysis methodologies (e.g. discrete choice models, interviews, surveys) often ignore these dependencies between the components and their consequences (e.g. feedback loops, non-linearity). Using methodologies that ignore these interactions could be an explanation why school segregation is still plaguing our educational systems. However, tools from complex systems such as Agent-Based Models (ABMs), can potentially be a complementary methodology that can explicitly account for such interactions and could therefore complement our understanding of the effect of them on school segregation.

In this talk, two examples of ABMs are presented which illustrate that a complexity perspective on school choice dynamics can meaningfully contribute to the field of school choice and school segregation. Firstly, using a highly stylised ABM, an alternative explanation of why schools are often more segregated relative to neighbourhoods is given. Households do not have to be less tolerant for school compositions compared to neighbourhood compositions. Instead, this ABM demonstrates that asymmetric preferences are not a requirement for excess school segregation, but that residential segregation combined with distance preferences and interacting components can also play a key role. However, these highly stylised models have limited applicability to reality and actual policy scenarios. Therefore, we also present ongoing work on a methodology to empirically calibrate large-scale ABMs on empirical data in the context of school choice. We show that this methodology is able to retrieve the (artificial) ground truth within reasonable accuracy. Additionally, (computational) challenges and open questions are discussed, focusing on the usage of household-level register data.

If you wish to to attend this seminar online, please send an email to w.merbis@uva.nl to receive the zoom-link.